1. Aluminum and steel cable trays differ significantly in material properties and applicable environments. Made of pure aluminum or rust-proof aluminum alloy, aluminum cable trays offer excellent corrosion resistance, requiring no additional anti-corrosion treatment. They weigh only one-third as much as steel, making them suitable for humid, coastal, and mildly corrosive environments. However, their mechanical strength is lower, with a tensile strength of only one-half to one-third that of ordinary carbon steel. They are susceptible to deformation under prolonged load or impact. Steel cable trays offer strong load-bearing capacity and excellent rigidity, making them suitable for densely packed cables, large spans, and locations with potential collision risks. However, their corrosion resistance is poor, requiring anti-corrosion treatments such as galvanizing and spray coating. Their weight also leads to higher transportation and installation costs.
2. The connection methods used for the two types of cable trays differ based on the material properties. Aluminum cable tray has a thermal expansion coefficient of approximately 23×10⁻⁶/°C, 1.6 times that of carbon steel. Long-distance installations exceeding 15 meters require expansion joints. Furthermore, direct contact between aluminum and steel or copper is prone to electrochemical corrosion. Connecting screws should be galvanized or stainless steel, and insulating gaskets should be used for isolation. Steel cable tray has a lower thermal expansion coefficient, making expansion joints less necessary for long-distance installations. Connecting fittings can be made of ordinary carbon steel, requiring only corrosion protection of the same material without additional isolation.
3. Grounding requirements are more stringent for aluminum cable trays due to their tendency to form a high-resistivity oxide film on their surface. Joints should be coated with a special conductive paste to break down the oxide film. Cross-connect grounding wires should use copper-aluminum transition terminals with a cross-sectional area of at least 4mm². Grounding should be performed every 30 meters for horizontal installations and every 20 meters for vertical installations. Grounding requirements for steel cable trays are more relaxed, requiring a grounding wire cross-sectional area of 2.5mm², and grounding spacing can be extended to 50 meters.
4. The two types exhibit different cost and maintenance characteristics. During initial procurement, aluminum bridge materials are expensive, costing approximately 1.5-2 times the cost of steel (including corrosion protection) for the same specifications. However, over the long term, steel bridges require re-corrosion protection every 3-5 years in corrosive environments, with maintenance costs estimated at 10-15 yuan per square meter. Aluminum bridges require virtually no maintenance and, with a service life of more than 10 years, offer lower lifecycle costs.




